Mystery Hat Challenge! is the 1st episode of the Smosh Games series Mystery Challenge, It was released on January 17, 2020.


Good day, m’ladies, m'gents, and m'everyone in between! Max Gentlemen with a mystery top hat challenge twist is, perhaps, the fanciest game we’ve ever played on this channel.


Mystery Item

The loser of each round must wear a top hat (or cowboy hat) filled with various food.


Round Player 1 vs. Player 2 Score Loser Hat
1 Damien vs. Matt 10-5 Matt Rainbow Candy
2 Courtney vs. Sarah 3-9 Courtney Confetti
3 Shayne vs. Lasercorn 9-4 Lasercorn Honey
4 Shayne vs. Sarah 11-6 Sarah Marshmallow Fluff
5 Shayne vs. Damien 11-8 Damien Apple Sauce

Fan Interaction

  • Smosh Games commented saying: "m'lady." It received over 1.1K likes.
  • Damien commented saying: "Legend has it that our hair is still sticky. Which of these punishments is the worst? For me, it's between two specific ones...." It receieved over 1.1K likes.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.