Kelly

Kelly was a piece of bread who was Ian's best friend in the episode HIDE AND SEEK until Ian got hungry and ate it.

How it Appeared
He appeared when Anthony was alone eating: Ian picked up the bread from Anthony's plate and put it with him and Ian drew a face for company.

Kelly seems to represent Ian's inner opposing thoughts before the hunger becomes unbearable, especially demonstrated when Kelly tries to convince Ian to finally come out of hiding.

Trivia/Notes

 * As mentioned on the BTS video, when Ian ate Kelly he was actually eating a different slice of bread that didn't have any marker on it.
 * Kelly is most likely a parody of Wilson the Volleyball from the movie Castaway.
 * Kelly is male because he tells Ian that he is a man after Ian ate him.